Topics:

Tragic Trends in the Treatment of Addictive Illness

Tragic Trends in the Treatment of Addictive Illness


Why do so many die as a consequence of addiction? Is it in the inexorable, “progressive” nature of the disease? Or might it be the result of entrenched treatment approaches that repeatedly and increasingly become misaligned with the needs of individuals suffering from addictive disorders? For example, some need, and don’t get:

• Safety, structure, and support
• Medications for symptom reduction and control
• Nurturance and comfort
• The company and “fellowship” of others
• Storytelling and group sharing to understand their “errant” ways

The list goes on, and every clinician could add what else might be needed or beneficial to address and provide for those suffering from addictive disorders.
There continues to be a need for professionals who treat addiction, as well as all health care providers, to continue to fine tune approaches that work best and to avoid approaches that are exclusive or doctrinaire.

I write this piece to reach an audience of those who suffer with addictive illness, those who witness it as caring friends and family, and to all clinicians who treat it. I do so to counter attitudes of stigma that diminish empathic concerns for the fate of addicted individuals, and attitudes of therapeutic despair that addictive disorders can engender. And finally, I write it to foster awareness of a problem in the addiction field, where parochial attitudes and practice can be harmful for individuals in need of treatment.

At any given time, we learn of the death of one more celebrity as the media blazons us with such tragic and unwelcome news, a most recent example being the death of Philip Seymour Hoffman. Their achievements and promise, and for some celebrities their notoriety, and the magnitude of such loss, bring us up short. We wonder what addiction is and why it results in deadly consequences. We are left to worry whether it could have been prevented. Celebrity status succeeds in drawing media attention to the scourge of addiction, but we must not forget the countless incidents throughout society, among the rich or poor, gifted or ordinary, and promising or stuck individuals who unheralded and ignominiously suffer the same fate.

Clearly effective models and approaches for understanding and treating addictive illness exist. These include 12-step programs, relapse prevention, cognitive behavioral approaches, harm reduction therapy, motivational interviewing, medications, and dialectical behavioral therapy. In my clinical experience, modified psychodynamic individual and group treatments are also extremely effective in addressing and resolving the emotional and behavioral problems that drive addictive disorders. Shedler1 has documented robust evidence that supports the efficacy of psychodynamic psychotherapy [See: PDF]. Few empirical studies show such approaches work for addicted populations, but Shedler’s findings apply to treatment of addictive disorders, in my experience. Such application needs further empirical study.

One of the problems in treating addictive disorders is polemics. The debates and controversies go on and date back a half century: Is addiction a disease or a symptom? Do psychiatric disorders cause addiction or is it the other way around? Is it environment or heredity? That debates are rancorous and often bitter is bad enough, but worse, they play out tragically in treatment when adherents of one approach or another rigidly apply a particular model alone to the exclusion of others.

Sadly—and in some cases disastrously—affected individuals are never offered alternative approaches after one option fails. Too often in my own practice, a patient is referred for consultation by a psychotherapist who has adopted a symptom approach alone, trying to get to root causes of drug and alcohol abuse without considering first the need to get the addictive behavior under control; or on the other hand, the patient who has tried and failed 12-step work for decades is told that he or she hasn’t bottomed out or “doesn’t want” sobriety.

Pages

 
Loading comments...

By clicking Accept, you agree to become a member of the UBM Medica Community.