Alternative Brief Interventions for Mild Depression

Alternative Brief Interventions for Mild Depression

Depression has long been recognized as a primary concern for health care providers.1-3 Many approaches to treating depression have been developed, ranging from medications, to long-term psychotherapy, to shorter, more structured cognitive-behavioral treatments--all of which help some of the patients, some of the time, to some extent. However, there are still many persons who never access treatment for reasons ranging from the stigma that still surrounds mental illness, to a lack of resources, both personal (eg, lack of money) and "professional" (eg, long wait for appointments). Furthermore, given the restrictions placed on practice by managed care, and the proliferation and success of brief, motivational enhancement treatments with other disorders, such as alcohol abuse,4,5 it is important to develop similar treatments for those with depression and/or depressed mood to augment existing treatment options.

There is a growing realization that depression exists on a continuum,6-9 and that treatments are needed at all levels of a "stepped-care" approach.10-12 In particular, those with mild symptoms of depression are less apt to seek treatment, yet they are at risk for development of a major depressive episode and experiencing other consequences of depressed mood.7,8,13,14

Two groups particularly underserved by the current treatment system are adolescents and college students. Research indicates that adolescents (aged up to 19 years) are the "least likely to be recognized, diagnosed, and treated in the health care system compared with [those with] depression in other age groups."15 College students are vulnerable because they often encounter increased stressors and incidents of depression and depressed mood while also facing barriers to treatment.16-19 However, treatment options for those with subclinical depression or depressed mood are bleak.3 Most receive no treatment for their symptoms; the Surgeon General recently stated that promoting treatment is a more significant problem than developing better treatments.20

Persons with less history of depression or those who are mildly depressed may best be helped with an educational, motivation-enhancement approach. Alternative, lower-cost, brief treatments are starting to emerge in an effort to reach persons with various levels of depressed mood. In addition to computer- and telephone-administered treatments,21-23 some writing and bibliotherapy approaches have been shown to reduce symptoms of depression.

Writing approaches

Writing brief narratives is a low-cost way of reducing depressed mood in college students and others. James W. Pennebaker has conducted dozens of studies over 15 years examining the cognitive, emotional, and language processes involved in writing short narrative disclosures.24 For example, writing about traumatic experiences for 10 minutes a day for several days or for even a single writing period has been shown to reduce health-center visits and improve grade point averages, immune function, hormonal activity, and subjective well being.25,26 Effect sizes in these studies ranged from 0.45 to 0.70, similar to those with other psychological treatments. The effects are presumed to occur through changing cognitions during the writing process. This activity forces the person to think about events and process the emotional and objective elements of the event, while reducing rumination. Results are obtained not merely through "venting" or "catharsis"; writing about only emotions without a description of the event itself did not show the same benefits.27

Writing about trauma also reduces the frequency and impact of intrusive thoughts about the event. Furthermore, writing changes how individuals interact with others, their patterns of speaking, use of self-reference, and use of positive emotion words, which brings about changes in objective social behaviors in the real world.25 Writing has also been compared with talking into a tape-recorder or to a therapist with comparable results in healthy subjects.27,28 This presents an inexpensive yet effective way to help patients feel better.

Reading approaches

A study looking at mildly to moderately depressed older adults found that bibliotherapy (reading books, such as Control Your Depression by Lewinsohn, Munoz, Youngren, and Zeiss, or Feeling Good by David Burns) was an effective form of treatment that reduced symptoms. The gains were maintained for up to 2 years with 77% of the patients not seeking other treatment.29


Loading comments...

By clicking Accept, you agree to become a member of the UBM Medica Community.