We've noticed that you're using an ad blocker

Our content is brought to you free of charge because of the support of our advertisers. To continue enjoying our content, please turn off your ad blocker.

It's off now Dismiss How do I disable my ad blocker?
❌

How to disable your ad blocker for our site:

Adblock / Adblock Plus
  • Click on the AdBlock / AdBlock Plus icon on the top right of your browser.
  • Click “Don’t run on pages on this domain.” OR “Enabled on this site.”
  • Close this help box and click "It's off now".
Firefox Tracking Prevention
  • If you are Private Browsing in Firefox, "Tracking Protection" may casue the adblock notice to show. It can be temporarily disabled by clicking the "shield" icon in the address bar.
  • Close this help box and click "It's off now".
Ghostery
  • Click the Ghostery icon on your browser.
  • In Ghostery versions < 6.0 click “Whitelist site.” in version 6.0 click “Trust site.”
  • Close this help box and click "It's off now".
uBlock / uBlock Origin
  • Click the uBlock / uBlock Origin icon on your browser.
  • Click the “power” button in the menu that appears to whitelist the current website
  • Close this help box and click "It's off now".
  • Topics
  • CME
  • Special Reports
  • Slideshows
  • Quizzes
  • Blogs
  • Conferences
  • Classifieds
  • Archives

Modern Medicine Network
  • Login
  • Register
Skip to main content
Modern Medicine Network
  • Login
  • Register
Menu
User
Home
  • Topics
  • CME
  • Special Reports
  • Slideshows
  • Quizzes
  • Blogs
  • Conferences
  • Classifieds
  • Archives

SUBSCRIBE: eNewsletter

The Early Psychiatrist: A Piercing Eye and Commanding Presence

  • Greg Eghigian, PhD
Mar 1, 2012
Volume: 
29
Issue: 
3
  • Histrionic Personality Disorder

Among the many changes in psychiatric practice often attributed to the psychotherapist Carl Rogers was a shift in the therapist’s relationship with the patient. In particular, Rogers is rightly famous for advocating “client-centered” or “person-centered” therapy.

As he put it, “This formulation would state that it is the counselor’s function to assume, in so far as he is able, the internal frame of reference of the client, to perceive the world as the client sees it, to perceive the client himself as he is seen by himself, and to lay aside all perceptions from the external frame of reference while doing so.”1(p86) In calling for a change in the therapist’s attitude and orientation toward those being treated, client-centered therapy is a response to overbearing psychoanalytic and behavioral therapies, ie, therapies built around rigid models applied by self-assured counselors.

What is often forgotten, however, is that things such as client-centered therapy, “mental hygiene,” and “self-help” were also responses to another phenomenon—the charismatic physician. In the premodern world, before doctors prescribed science and began using an arsenal of instruments, they relied primarily on their experience, skills of observation, and bedside manner to treat patients: the key was to establish and maintain the patient’s trust.2

The role of the physician was partly performative, ie, it was necessary to actively instill confidence in his or her talents and expertise. At the same time, patients were notorious for their reluctance to follow orders. They had a habit of complaining and a penchant for self-diagnosis and self-medication. These patterns continued during the 1800s, when academically trained physicians widely experienced a marked social mobility, entering the ranks of the privileged middle class. The result was that doctors in the 19th and early 20th centuries often assumed an officious air of superiority.2

Things were no different within the specialty of psychiatry. When the first specialists referred to as “mad-doctors” began to emerge in the late 18th century, the force of their personalities was often seen as the key to the success of their treatments. Rev Dr Francis Willis (1718 - 1807)—the man enlisted to treat King George III’s apparent madness from 1788 to 1789—was purported to have an almost magical gaze, described as: “He suddenly became a different figure commanding the respect even of maniacs. His piercing eye seemed to read their hearts and divine their thoughts as they formed and before they were even uttered. In this way he gained control over them which he used as a means of cure.”3

Philippe Pinel (1745 - 1826), credited with removing the use of chains and introducing talk therapy (“the moral treatment”) in asylums, nevertheless insisted on the necessity of applying a mental “force evidently and convincingly superior”4 when confronting “maniacs.” This included the staging of what he termed “pious frauds,” such as giving one delusional patient the impression that staff would beat him up if he continued to refuse to eat his meals.4

The power psychiatrists wielded over their charges was hardly deemed an ethical challenge or a necessary evil. Far from it. In Germany—where the asylum director was referred to as the “asylum father” (Anstaltsvater)—the role of the alienist or psychiatrist was modeled on the prevailing ideal of the domestic household: the wise director treated his residents as naive and misguided children who required constant supervision and correction.

Pages

  • 1
  • 2
  • next ›
  • last »
References: 

References

1. Rogers CR. The attitude and orientation of the counselor in client-centered therapy. J Consult Psychol. 1949;13:82-94.
2. Porter R. The Greatest Benefit to Mankind: A Medical History of Humanity. New York: WW Norton & Company, Inc; 1997:58-59, 668-672.
3. Macalpine I, Hunter R. George III and the Mad-Business. London: Pimlico; 1995:270-272.
4. Pinel P. A Treatise on Insanity. Sheffield, England: Todd; 1806.
5. Heinroth JC. Textbook of Disturbances of Mental Life, or Disturbances of the Soul and Their Treatment. Vol 1. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press; 1975:29.
6. Goldstein J. Console and Classify: The French Psychiatric Profession in the Nineteenth Century. New York: Cambridge University Press; 1987:169-171.
7. Eghigian G. From Madness to Mental Health: Psychiatric Disorder and Its Treatment in Western Civil­ization. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press; 2010:237.
8. The Lobotomist. From the PBS documentary series The American Experience. WGBH Educational Foundation; 2008. http://www.wgbh.org/programs/-97/episodes/The-Lobotomist-11466. Accessed December 14, 2011.

Related Articles

  • A Patient with Dissociative Identity Disorder 'Switches' in the Emergency Room
  • Introduction to Culture-Bound Syndromes
  • A Complicated Process: Diagnosing and Treating Anorexia Nervosa and Bulimia
  • Bioterrorism Looms Are We Prepared?
  • Personality Disorders in Employment Litigation

Resource Topics rightRail

  • Resource Topics
  • Partner Content
ADHD
Schizophrenia
Bipolar Disorder
Geriatric Psychiatry
Major Depressive Disorder
Smart IOP – A New Kind of Intensive Outpatient Program
Three Things Mental Health Professionals Need to Know About Telemedicine – TODAY!
How Telemedicine Can Transform Patient Engagement

Current Issue

Psychiatric Times Vol 35 No 3
Mar 12, 2018 Vol 32 No 3
Digital Edition
Subscribe
Connect with Us
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
Modern Medicine Network
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Advertiser Terms
  • Privacy statement
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Editorial & Advertising Policy
  • Editorial Board
  • Contact Us
Modern Medicine Network
© UBM 2018, All rights reserved.
Reproduction in whole or in part is prohibited.