PsychiatricTimes Members: Login | Register

|     

PsychiatricTimes SearchMedica Medline Drugs

Powered by SearchMedica

 
Risk Assessment
News
Current Issues
Blogs
Special Reports
CME
Conferences
Resources
Careers
Multimedia
About Us
 

Home » Blogs » Couch in Crisis

Psychiatric Times.
 

Celebrating Death

By James L. Knoll IV, MD | May 3, 2011
Dr Knoll is associate professor of psychiatry at the SUNY Upstate Medical Center in Syracuse, NY, where he is director of forensic psychiatry, and director of the forensic psychiatry fellowship at Central New York Psychiatric Center. He is also the editor in chief of Psychiatric Times. His brother, a Major in the United States Army, served 2 tours in Iraq.

A general is well advised
To achieve nothing more than his orders:
Not to take advantage of his victory.
Nor to glory, boast or pride himself;
To do what is dictated by necessity,
Not by choice.

For even the strongest force will weaken with time,
And then its violence will return, and kill it.

—Lao Tzu (circa 6th century B.C.)

Not long after the surreal images of planes flying into New York City skyscrapers, there were celebrations in other countries in response to this unfathomable tragedy.  Let us consider this behavioral evidence carefully.  Recently, there were jubilant celebrations in reaction to the death of Osama Bin Laden. Let us consider this too.

In choosing to live and kill like a terrorist, it seems as though one also chooses to die like a terrorist. This was Bin Laden's fate. Although he could not have foreseen the exact details, he chose his meeting with Navy Seals a long time ago. Thus, the ending to his life was just so.

And now we have a chance to reflect on what this means, how we react, and how we progress from here.  There is much to consider, as taking a life always has consequences.  For now, let us consider our own reactions. This is but another chapter in a continuing, sad, violent saga.  911 victims are still gone. The man that set this tragedy in motion has met his self chosen fate.   Relief.  A sense of justice. Catharsis. These are understandable human reactions. 

Can this be something to celebrate? Should it be something to celebrate?  What can this tell us about ourselves?  What is the "proper" reaction?  Remaining in a state of uncertainty, I bow my head and move on….

 

Join the Conversation

Want to join the conversation? If you're a healthcare professional, we'd like to hear your comments. Just sign in or register today to become part of our growing, online community.

  • Oldest First
  • Newest First

by sharon braccini | May 11, 2011 5:56 AM EDT

Thank you....Very well stated! And I love the Lao Tzu quote.

by Ronald Pies | May 03, 2011 11:17 PM EDT

My colleague and friend James Knoll is raising an important ethical issue, and one with many psychological dimensions, as well. In the Judaic tradition, we are taught not to "rejoice"when one's enemy has fallen. Indeed, as healers, we are inclined by nature to look with disapproval upon any sort of "celebration" when another human being dies. However, the Judaic tradition does allow us to rejoice when evil and injustice are defeated. The distinction is subtle, and perhaps many Americans have not taken it to heart. Celebrating the death of a fellow human being--even one who has committed unspeakable crimes--is unseemly, and inconsistent with humane values. But taking visible satisfaction in the undoing of a terrible malefactor is understandable and even morally appropriate, if carried out with restraint and decorum. --Ron Pies MD

by CECILIA LEONARD | May 03, 2011 6:10 PM EDT

Well said - even though killing others might be part of a military mission, we should never REJOICE at the demise of another.






 
TOPIC INDEX

Addiction Medicine
Alzheimer Disease
Anxiety Disorders
ADHD
Bipolar Disorder
Child & Adolescent Psychiatry
Dementia
Depression
DSM-5
Geriatric Psychiatry

 

Health Care Reform
Major Depressive
Disorder
OCD
Personality Disorders
Schizoaffective Disorder
Schizophrenia
Sleep Disorders
Somatoform Disorders
All Topics

 


 
FROM PHYSICIANS PRACTICE
Five Steps to Improving Patient Access
Judy Capko,  May 21, 2013
Patient access is getting increased attention through reform initiatives. Here are five steps you can take to make sure patients get appropriate access to care in your office.
Growing HIPAA Threat – Ignore Windows XP at Your Own Peril
Marion K. Jenkins,  May 21, 2013
Chances are good that you have some major ticking software time bombs lurking in your medical practice's computer environment, namely Windows XP and Server 2003.
Finding Physician Work-Life Balance in the Small Moments
Jennifer Frank, MD,  May 21, 2013
At my practice and at home, things are always busy. There's laundry or homework, or a patient with needs.
Three Areas to Reduce Costs at Your Medical Practice
Greg Mertz,  May 19, 2013
By taking a hard look at reducing costs for staffing, overhead, and technology at your medical practice, you may see increased physician compensation.
Dos and Don’ts for Starting a Physician Blog
Michael Woo-Ming, MD,  May 18, 2013
Starting a physician blog can provide your medical practice with marketing benefits, but it's important to do it right.
 

 

 
MOST POPULAR
  • Most Popular
  • Most Emailed
  • Most Recent
  • Developmental Psychopathology Comes of Age
  • The Moral Struggles of Practicing Psychiatrists
  • Grief and Depression: The Sages Knew the Difference
  • Update on Mental Health Benefits and Substance Use Disorder Services Under the Affordable Care Act
  • Synthetic Cathinones: Signs, Symptoms, and Treatment
  • Grief and Depression: The Sages Knew the Difference
  • Successful Aging: Strategies to Help Maintain and Nurture a Healthy Brain
  • Developmental Psychopathology Comes of Age
  • Synthetic Cathinones: Signs, Symptoms, and Treatment
  • Psychiatry and the Myth of “Medicalization”
  • Experts Discuss Changes, Updates in DSM-5
  • The Paradox of Choice: When More Medications Mean Less Treatment
  • Will Your Clinical Records Support You in Court?
  • Refinements in ECT Techniques
  • Successful Aging: Strategies to Help Maintain and Nurture a Healthy Brain
Click here to subscribe to our newsletter
 
COMMENTS
  • Most Commented
  • Most Recent
  • Psychiatry and the Myth of “Medicalization”
  • Grief and Depression: The Sages Knew the Difference
  • Is it Time for a Treatment Manual to Complement DSM-5?
  • Diagnosis and its Discontents: The DSM Debate Continues
  • Lamotrigine for Major Depressive Disorder Is Inappropriate
  • New Insight Into the Neurobiology of Depression
  • Tie One On for Patients
  • NIMH vs DSM 5: No One Wins, Patients Lose
  • Psychiatry and the Myth of “Medicalization”
  • Parity Laws: Powerful Weapon—or Pipe Dream?
Click here to subscribe to our newsletter


 
CAREER CENTER

  •   Featured Jobs  
  •    Resources   
  • Psychiatry and Nurse Practitioner Opportunities
  • Associate Medical Director - Psychiatrist Delray Beach, Florida
  • Retiring Child Psychiatrist Seeks Replacement August 2010 or Before
  • Chairperson, Dept of Psychiatry Needed
  • FT Staff Psychiatrist - Excellent Benefits
  • BC Adult and Child Psychiatrits - PT and FT Positions Available
  • Managing Risks When Practicing in Three-Party Care Settings
  • 12 Tips for Making Your Practice Greener
  • Keys to Avoiding Malpractice: Standard of Care in Psychiatric Practice
  • Take This Job and Shove It
  • Merging Administrative and Academic Careers in Psychiatry


CancerNetwork | ConsultantLive | Diagnostic Imaging | Musculoskeletal Network | OBGYN.net | PediatricsConsultantLive |
Physicians Practice | Psychiatric Times | SearchMedica | Medical Resources

© 1996 - 2013 UBM Medica LLC, a UBM company
Privacy Statement - Terms of Service - Advertising Information - Editorial Policy Statement - UBM Medica Network Privacy Policy