ubmslatePT-logo-ubm

PT Mobile Logo

Search form

Topics:

8 Distinguishing Features of Primary Psychosis Versus Cannabis-Induced Psychosis

8 Distinguishing Features of Primary Psychosis Versus Cannabis-Induced Psychosis

  • As cannabis consumption rises, there has been significant emerging evidence for cannabis-related risks. Here: a comparison of the clinical features of idiopathic psychosis (eg, schizophrenia) versus cannabis-induced psychosis (CIP). Scroll through the slides for 8 distinguishing features.

  • Primary psychosis (eg, schizophrenia). Cannabis urine toxicology is sometimes positive.
    CIP. A positive toxicology screen indicates a clear timeline. Time of last drug ingestion will indicate if a patient’s psychotic symptoms are closely related to cannabis intoxication/withdrawal effects.
    Discussion. Clear features of CIP are sudden onset of mood lability and paranoid symptoms, within 1 week of use but as early as 24 hours after use. CIP is commonly precipitated by a sudden increase in potency (eg, percent of THC content or quantity of cannabis consumption; typically, heavy users of cannabis consume more than 2 g/d). Criteria for CIP must exclude primary psychosis, and symptoms should be in excess of expected intoxication and withdrawal effects.

  • Primary psychosis. Variable reported cannabis use (25% prevalence of positive cannabis urine toxicology in schizophrenia). A diagnosis of primary psychosis (eg, schizophrenia) is warranted in the absence of heavy cannabis use or withdrawal (for at least 4 weeks), or if symptoms preceded onset of heavy use.
    CIP. Heavy cannabis use within the past month.
    Discussion. A diagnosis of primary psychosis (eg, schizophrenia) is warranted in the absence of heavy cannabis use or withdrawal (for at least 4 weeks), or if symptoms preceded onset of heavy use. The age at which psychotic symptoms emerge has not proved to be a helpful indicator; different studies show a conflicting median age of onset.

  • Primary psychosis. Symptoms appear before heavy substance use.
    CIP. Symptoms appear only during periods of heavy substance use/sudden increase in potency.
    Discussion. CIP has historically been associated with fewer negative symptoms than schizophrenia; however, without a clear timeline of use, distinguishing schizophrenia from CIP may prove difficult. Clinical features of schizophrenia and CIP share many overlapping characteristics. However, compared with primary psychoses with concurrent cannabis abuse, CIP has been established to show more mood symptoms than primary psychosis.

  • Primary psychosis. Symptoms persist despite drug abstinence.
    CIP. Symptoms abate or are reduced with drug abstinence.
    Discussion. When assessing for CIP, careful history taking is critical. Time of last drug ingestion will indicate if a patient’s psychotic symptoms are closely related to cannabis intoxication/withdrawal effects.

  • Primary psychosis. Antipsychotics markedly improve symptoms.
    CIP. Antipsychotics may or may not improve symptoms.
    Discussion. Pharmacotherapeutic interventions include the second-generation antipsychotic drug olanzapine and haloperidol. While both are equally effective, their different adverse- effect profiles should be taken into consideration when treating a patient; olanzapine is associated with significantly fewer extrapyramidal adverse effects.

  • Primary psychosis. Most often presents with delusions, hallucinations, and thought disorder.
    CIP. Often associated with visual hallucinations and paranoid ideation ( eg, features of an “organic” psychosis.
    Discussion. While acute cannabis intoxication presents with a range of transient positive symptoms (paranoia, grandiosity, perceptual alterations), mood symptoms (anxiety), and cognitive deficits (working memory, verbal recall, attention), symptoms that persist beyond the effects of intoxication and withdrawal are better categorized as CIP, regardless of the route of administration (smoke inhalation, oral, intravenous).

  • Primary psychosis. Less insight about psychotic state.
    CIP. More aware of symptoms/insight about disease.
    Discussion. Perhaps the most discriminating characteristic of CIP is awareness of the clinical condition, greater disease insight, and the ability to identify symptoms as a manifestation of a mental disorder or substance use. The presence of much more rapidly declining positive symptoms is another distinctive factor of CIP.

  • Primary psychosis. Disorganized thought form (eg, loose associations, tangential or circumstantial speech).
    CIP. Thought form or more organized and sequential.
    Discussion. CIP has historically been associated with fewer negative symptoms than schizophrenia; however, without a clear timeline of use, distinguishing schizophrenia from CIP may prove difficult. The role of long-term antipsychotic treatment after CIP also needs further research. Ultimately, strategies geared to prevention of CIP are critical (eg, cannabis treatment, drug use prevention).

  • Treatment of CIP
    As with all substance-induced psychotic states, abstinence from cannabis may be the definitive measure to prevent recurrence. With limited research surrounding CIP, achieving symptomatic treatment during acute phases of CIP has proved to be difficult. The Figure suggests possible treatment progression for CIP. For a mobile-friendly view of the figure, click here.

  • For more on this topic, see Cannabis-Induced Psychosis: A Review, by Ruby S. Grewal, MD and Tony P. George, MD, FRCPC, on which this slideshow is based.

View the slides in PDF format.

Comments

Antipsychotics don't work all that well for schizophrenia either - particularly in chronic rather than first episode psychosis. Even with treatment, only 5% of patients with schizophrenia are able to return to full work and family function.

Psychosis no matter the cause still needs treatment because the consequences of non-treatment is serious.

Given the frequent use of drugs by patients with schizophrenia, a clean distinction between Cannabis-induced psychosis and Schizophrenia is difficult. At the county mental health level, cannabis use is much more frequent than than the 20% indicated in this article.

It isn't enough to ask the patient for abstinence from drug use.

Romeo @

It really is WRONG the way people will put down cannabis, where in MY situation, smoking it has saved my life. I have severe ptsd as well as anorexia, AND i am a recovering addict from Opiates. I am trying to stay away from pills and stay herbal. So while you all put down what GOD has put on earth, go ahead and put the pills in your body and kill yourself off faster, cause thats what pills do.
I on the other hand, will smoke my joint and eat.
Have a great day

Nicole @

Good article.
Many patients are not honest to provide real history. They tried to prove that they are psychotic due to schizo rather than substance induced psychosis!

I am not sure, antipsychotic can be use as a prophylaxis for cannabis abuser but I am sure, persistent cannabis abuse can change COMT gene and end up in permanent abnormal dopamine metabolism resulting in persistent psychosis.

Sureshkumar @

"symptoms that persist beyond the effects of intoxication and withdrawal are better categorized as CIP, regardless of the route of administration (smoke inhalation, oral, intravenous)" --not sure what this statement means, but the slideshow differentiating CIP from organic psychotic illness is useful. I wonder if 'spice' or 'bathsalts intoxication' or some other poisons can be compared similarly (as CIP) to schizophrenia psychosis.

C. Nakajima RPh

Catharine @

Valuable presentation. I'm treating someone who may have CIP but this was not diagnosed in the ED visit before referral to me, even though his DAU screen was positive for cannabis. I've discovered that the local labs (and county jails) do a rather cursory drug screen that is missing synthetic cannabis and other street drugs that could be contributing to psychosis (and risk of death). In my own practice, I'd send out to specialize lab, especially for youth with psychosis facing a burden of (mis) diagnosis of schizophrenia etc.

DessyeDee @

Thank you. Useful SUCCINT comparison! To me the main distinguishing feature of Schizophrenia is the presence of so-called "negative symptoms" - shallow, blunted, and/or incongruent Affect, apathy, etc. Loose associations [e.g., circumstantial or derailed] are also somewhat suggestive. As your article suggests, Drug-induced [and for that matter all other Neuromedical and/or Medication-induced] Psychosis is primarily evidenced by so-called "positive" symptoms: i.e., delusions and hallucinations, including visual and possibly others in addition to auditory. I would also add to be constantly vigilant for a Mood Disorder [Depression or Bipolar] when a patient has Psychosis. As a colleague once said, a diagnosis of Schizophrenia is one that I do not make lightly; I want to have a low threshold for considering all other possible causes of Psychosis before consigning a patient to the grim diagnosis of Schizophrenia.

Perry @

J thet

Irwin @

Good article! Do we have a trustable description of Cannabis withdrawal symptoms and its natural history?
A remake of the games around another, more incisive hallucinogen, LSD, seems existing today, at least for non-professional audience, a documentary movie about rock group 'Pink Floyd', and the fate of their head around 1967, Syd Barrett, on LSD, may have some interest.

Jose @

Interesting presentation. I admitted a 25 yr old male this evening acutely psychotic , stating it was because of " the weed" . Has been doing street drugs since early teens, college graduate, now can't work 2 to " all republicans out to get him for the past 6 months"
Question ? What about genetic predisposition with psychosis after THC use. This family denied any psychosis in extended family.

Susan @

Add new comment

 
Loading comments...

By clicking Accept, you agree to become a member of the UBM Medica Community.