PsychiatricTimes Members: Login | Register

|     

PsychiatricTimes SearchMedica Medline Drugs

Powered by SearchMedica

 
Risk Assessment
News
Current Issues
Blogs
Special Reports
CME
Conferences
Resources
Careers
Multimedia
About Us
 

Home » Special Reports

Psychiatric Times. Vol. 29 No. 3
Pages: 1  2  3  4  5  6  7  
Previous Next
VANGUARD ISSUES IN PSYCHIATRY 

Enlightenment and Dimmed Enlightenment

Psychiatrists, Cast Off Your Distrust of Faith

By Herman M. van Praag, MD, PhD | March 2, 2012
Dr Van Praag is Emeritus Professor of Psychiatry at the universities of Groningen, Utrecht, and Maastricht, the Netherlands, and the Albert Einstein College of Medicine, New York. He reports no conflicts of interest concerning the subject matter of this article.

Evidence

We now return to the main discussion: religious faith is, in principle, a bright spot, a potential source of light. What evidence supports that thesis?

(MORE: Are Animal Models Relevant in Modern Psychiatry?)

My first argument is that “thinking upward” is not a gratuitous business. It leads to something, and with it one gains access to the metaphysical world. A world beyond the horizon—a world completely irrational that is impervious to rational, logical analysis. That world is not empty: humans cannot easily manage a vacuum, they tend to fill it up. A lull in a conversation is filled with words; in the case of a metaphysical universe, with undeterminable forces that influence one’s life as well as that of the community of which one is part. The forces imagined to operate in this metaphysical universe, may remain vague, unformed, noncommittal; this I call spirituality. Alternatively, the forces fancied are brought together in one, omnipresent, omnipotent, all-embracing mythical being, called God; this I call religiosity.

I use the term “mythical” not to denigrate. On the contrary, I consider myth as a superior way to express in a narrative, symbolic way experiences that are tenuous, those that cannot be concretely defined but are nevertheless intense and full of meaning and significance. The God-myth is of that nature. It is solidly rooted in human society, and its influence there has been profound and permanent.

For men of faith, that conception, that effigy, that likeness of God acquires a variety of functions. I will mention some. It is, first of all, a symbol of unlimited creativity and ultimate morality. As such it becomes for the faithful a role model, a touchstone for one’s own behavior>—imitatio deï. It is held as an absolute unattainable ideal, and at the same time, as a supreme guide for life. In his capacity of sublime example, God encroaches on man’s conscience, integrates with his conscience. In that capacity, God warns him when he threatens to go astray and stirs up guilt feelings if that happens.

The word symbol, metaphor, just like the concept myth, lacks any denigrating connotation. A metaphor is the very means to express verbally something actually impossible to catch in words. It provides an image of something ineffable and unimaginable.

Moreover, both fatherly and motherly qualities are projected in an idealized form in the God-effigy. In the experiential world of the faithful, God is both advisor and supreme protector. He steps in during times of emotional upheaval and provides solace or resignation, as needed.

Finally, God, as perceived by the faithful, has expectations. He expects man to sanctify life, to single out a destination with an altruistic character. A destination that contributes to the well-being of a society on a social, cultural, or scientific level. The destination can be less lofty but no less important by trying to make the best of one’s family or one’s professional and social life.

Pages: 1  2  3  4  5  6  7  
Previous Next
 

Join the Conversation

Want to join the conversation? If you're a healthcare professional, we'd like to hear your comments. Just sign in or register today to become part of our growing, online community.

  • Oldest First
  • Newest First

by Ronald Pies | March 02, 2012 10:03 PM EST

I applaud Prof. van Praag for defending the realm of religious experience against the scientism that often attacks it, sometimes in the name of "science."And, I agree with Prof. van Praag that the psychiatrist
"... cannot, with impunity, disregard an important domain of man's personality makeup. He ought to remain a searcher of the soul at large."

In discussing these matters, I prefer the term "religious impulse" to "religiosity" (since the latter may connote "exaggerated or affected piety and religious zeal"); and, I prefer "arational" or "supra-rational" to "irrational" (which may connote "loss of usual or normal mental clarity; incoherent"). Thus, the religious impulse, which is "receptive to the concept of God" (as Prof. van Praag puts it), is marked neither by zealotry nor
loss of mental clarity; it simply represents the human spirit yearning to rise above and beyond itself.

Many great scientists, such as Isaac Newton, were deeply imbued with the religious impulse. In this regard, I am reminded of Einstein's famous dictum: "Science without religion is lame. Religion without science is blind."

Ref: Pies R. The anatomy of sorrow: a spiritual, phenomenological, and neurological perspective.
Philos Ethics Humanit Med. 2008 Jun 17;3:17

Also in this Special Report

Introduction: Controversies and Evolving Issues

Condemning Torture and Abuse: A Call to Action

A Delicate Brain: Ethical and Practical Considerations for the Use of Medications in Very Young Children

Who Was Karen Horney?

Antipsychotics for Behavioral Disturbance in Dementia? A Clinical Conundrum

Neuroscientific Mirages: Are We No More Than Our Brains?

Are Animal Models Relevant in Modern Psychiatry?

Enlightenment and Dimmed Enlightenment

VANGUARD ISSUES IN PSYCHIATRY

Introduction: Controversies and Evolving Issues

Condemning Torture and Abuse: A Call to Action

A Delicate Brain: Ethical and Practical Considerations for the Use of Medications in Very Young Children

Who Was Karen Horney?

Antipsychotics for Behavioral Disturbance in Dementia? A Clinical Conundrum

Enlightenment and Dimmed Enlightenment

Are Animal Models Relevant in Modern Psychiatry?






 
TOPIC INDEX

Addiction Medicine
Alzheimer Disease
Anxiety Disorders
ADHD
Bipolar Disorder
Child & Adolescent Psychiatry
Dementia
Depression
DSM-5
Geriatric Psychiatry

 

Health Care Reform
Major Depressive
Disorder
OCD
Personality Disorders
Schizoaffective Disorder
Schizophrenia
Sleep Disorders
Somatoform Disorders
All Topics

 


 
FROM PHYSICIANS PRACTICE
Five Steps to Improving Patient Access
Judy Capko,  May 21, 2013
Patient access is getting increased attention through reform initiatives. Here are five steps you can take to make sure patients get appropriate access to care in your office.
Growing HIPAA Threat – Ignore Windows XP at Your Own Peril
Marion K. Jenkins,  May 21, 2013
Chances are good that you have some major ticking software time bombs lurking in your medical practice's computer environment, namely Windows XP and Server 2003.
Finding Physician Work-Life Balance in the Small Moments
Jennifer Frank, MD,  May 21, 2013
At my practice and at home, things are always busy. There's laundry or homework, or a patient with needs.
Three Areas to Reduce Costs at Your Medical Practice
Greg Mertz,  May 19, 2013
By taking a hard look at reducing costs for staffing, overhead, and technology at your medical practice, you may see increased physician compensation.
Dos and Don’ts for Starting a Physician Blog
Michael Woo-Ming, MD,  May 18, 2013
Starting a physician blog can provide your medical practice with marketing benefits, but it's important to do it right.
 

 

 
MOST POPULAR
  • Most Popular
  • Most Emailed
  • Most Recent
  • The Moral Struggles of Practicing Psychiatrists
  • Developmental Psychopathology Comes of Age
  • Grief and Depression: The Sages Knew the Difference
  • Update on Mental Health Benefits and Substance Use Disorder Services Under the Affordable Care Act
  • Experts Discuss Changes, Updates in DSM-5
  • Successful Aging: Strategies to Help Maintain and Nurture a Healthy Brain
  • You Are—And Your Mood Is—What You Eat
  • Grief and Depression: The Sages Knew the Difference
  • Experts Discuss Changes, Updates in DSM-5
  • Synthetic Cathinones: Signs, Symptoms, and Treatment
  • The Psychiatrist and the Slot Machine
  • The Role of Biological Tests in Psychiatric Diagnosis
  • You Are—And Your Mood Is—What You Eat
  • Experts Discuss Changes, Updates in DSM-5
  • The Paradox of Choice: When More Medications Mean Less Treatment
Click here to subscribe to our newsletter
 
COMMENTS
  • Most Commented
  • Most Recent
  • Grief and Depression: The Sages Knew the Difference
  • Psychiatry and the Myth of “Medicalization”
  • Is it Time for a Treatment Manual to Complement DSM-5?
  • NIMH vs DSM 5: No One Wins, Patients Lose
  • DSM-5 Won’t Solve the Overdiagnosis Problem—But Clinicians Can
  • Experts Discuss Changes, Updates in DSM-5
  • The Role of Biological Tests in Psychiatric Diagnosis
  • Successful Aging: Strategies to Help Maintain and Nurture a Healthy Brain
  • Refinements in ECT Techniques
  • DSM-5 Won’t Solve the Overdiagnosis Problem—But Clinicians Can
Click here to subscribe to our newsletter

  •   Featured Jobs  
  •    Resources   
  • Psychiatry and Nurse Practitioner Opportunities
  • Associate Medical Director - Psychiatrist Delray Beach, Florida
  • Retiring Child Psychiatrist Seeks Replacement August 2010 or Before
  • Chairperson, Dept of Psychiatry Needed
  • FT Staff Psychiatrist - Excellent Benefits
  • BC Adult and Child Psychiatrits - PT and FT Positions Available
  • Managing Risks When Practicing in Three-Party Care Settings
  • 12 Tips for Making Your Practice Greener
  • Keys to Avoiding Malpractice: Standard of Care in Psychiatric Practice
  • Take This Job and Shove It
  • Merging Administrative and Academic Careers in Psychiatry

CancerNetwork | ConsultantLive | Diagnostic Imaging | Musculoskeletal Network | OBGYN.net | PediatricsConsultantLive |
Physicians Practice | Psychiatric Times | SearchMedica | Medical Resources

© 1996 - 2013 UBM Medica LLC, a UBM company
Privacy Statement - Terms of Service - Advertising Information - Editorial Policy Statement - UBM Medica Network Privacy Policy