- Psychiatric Times Vol 13 No 8
- Volume 13
- Issue 8
SSRIs
Many of the advantages of the MAOIs are seen with selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors, which have become the drugs of choice in the treatment of panic disorder.
Many of the advantages of the MAOIs are seen with selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors, which have become the drugs of choice in the treatment of panic disorder.
Even though few large-scale, placebo-controlled studies are available (Oehrberg and coworkers; Den Boer and Westenberg 1988 and 1990; Black and others) SSRIs have essentially become a first-line treatment for panic disorder as reflected in uncontrolled trials (Gorman and others; Schneier and others) and clinical practice.
When compared to TCAs, SSRIs cause fewer anticholinergic effects and fewer cardiac effects, such as orthostatic hypotension, palpitations and dizziness. As mentioned previously, these latter two side effects can mimic a panic attack and frighten the patient. SSRIs cause less sedation and weight gain as compared with TCAs. When compared to MAOIs, SSRIs do not have the dietary constrictions and also cause less orthostatic hypotension. SSRIs do not have the abuse potential of the benzodiazepines.
The initial approach to the treatment of panic with SSRIs is listed in
Though paroxetine (Paxil) has been recently approved by the FDA for treatment of panic disorder, there are no studies to suggest that it has any special efficacy over the other SSRIs for this syndrome.
Combination Treatment
Although no controlled evidence exists for this approach, in many clinical settings a combination of a low-dose benzodiazepine and antidepressant is frequently given. In general, this combination is safe and beneficial as the drugs tend to complement each other by having differing effects on the aspects of panic disorder. Benzodiazepines block the activation of antidepressants in addition to alleviating anticipatory anxiety while antidepressants (which are slower to act) block the panic attack and also alleviate comorbid depressive symptoms.
The strategy is to hold the individual on low-dose benzodiazepines (e.g., alprazolam 0.25 to 0.5 mg tid or qid plus antidepressant) for four to eight weeks. When the patient's panic has abated and antidepressant levels are adequate, the benzodiazepine can be slowly withdrawn. For some individuals who experience symptom worsening upon withdrawal of the benzodiazepine, it may be necessary to continue the patient on the combination for longer periods of time.
For individuals who fail on monotherapy, a combination of TCA plus SSRI is occasionally used in the treatment of panic disorder (Coplan and colleagues). This requires an extremely cautious approach as SSRIs inhibit the hepatic cytochrome P450 2 D6 (as well as 3A4 and 1A2) system and interfere with the metabolism of TCAs, causing marked increases in TCA levels with the end result being severe cardiac toxicity. Though controversies exist as to the quantitative differences between the three SSRIs in elevating tricyclic levels (Preskorn and colleagues; Harvey and Preskorn; Nemeroff and others), it appears that fluoxetine and paroxetine elevate tricyclic levels more than sertraline does. Sertraline appears to have less inhibition of the hepatic TCA metabolism. For patients who receive a TCA-SSRI combination, TCA blood levels and electrocardiograms should be monitored frequently.
Alternative Treatments
Clonidine (Catapres) at doses of 0.2 to 0.5 mg per day has been found to have some effects in the treatment of panic disorder in one open (Liebowitz and colleagues 1981) and one double-blind crossover study (Hoehn-Saric). (The main effect of clonidine in the Hoehn-Saric study was a decrease of anxiety attacks and "psychic" symptoms. Somatic symptoms were least affected. The conditions of 17 percent of the patients became worse with the medication- Ed.) Its usage, either alone or in combination, however, appeared somewhat limited secondary to such side effects as drowsiness, sedation, fatigue, weakness and dizziness.
Calcium channel blockers have found some success in the treatment of panic disorder. Goldstein noted some success for both diltiazem (Cardizem) (60 mg per day) and verapamil (Calan) (80 mg per day), and in a double-blind crossover study, Klein and Uhde noted some benefit for seven of 11 patients treated with verapamil. Because of the possibility of cardiac side effects, EKG, blood pressure and pulse should be monitored. Similarly, because of these effects, combination treatment with calcium channel blockers should be cautiously undertaken.
Anticonvulsants have recently gained some attention in panic disorder. Though an initial double-blind placebo controlled study found carbamazepine (Tegretol) ineffective for panic disorder, Tondo and colleagues noted improvement in 20 of 34 patients treated with 170 to 500 mg per day of carbamazepine for two to 12 months. Open and double-blind crossover studies with valproate have yielded some success in panic disorder (Lum and colleagues; Woodman and Noyes). Despite the small numbers, doses of valproate in the range of 1,000 to 2,000 mg per day have decreased the length and intensity of panic attacks with minimal side effects.
Length of Treatment
It is pretty clear that panic disorder is a life-long problem as 50 percent of patients suffer continuous symptoms despite adequate treatment (Peselow and colleagues). Though no firm evidence exists, many clinicians feel that patients who respond should be maintained on the treatment for nine months to two years (Coplan and others 1996). After this length of time, discontinuation can be considered.
Fyer and colleagues found high rates of relapse if the drug is withdrawn quickly. Consequently, a slow taper (from three to six months) is often indicated. Chances for a patient to be successfully withdrawn from medication completely are small. It has been often felt that cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) in conjunction with pharmacotherapy may help with the discontinuation process and decrease the possibility of relapse (Black and others). In the event of relapse upon discontinuation, the medication should be restarted and continued over the same interval.
Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy
Cognitive-behavioral therapy is often considered an effective treatment for panic disorder (Barlow and others 1984, 1989). There are those who regard it as a first-line treatment for panic disorder with some considering it to be as or more effective than medication (Clark and others). Though this is highly controversial, it is clear that for individuals with phobic avoidance in conjunction with the panic, CBT's use of imagery and in vivo exposure has been found to benefit this specific population.
As noted, for those with incomplete response to medication, a trial of cognitive therapy (including thought restructuring, relaxation training and in vivo exposure to phobic situations) and education about the illness is often helpful for both acute and long-term treatment. Though there are virtually no data regarding the combined approach, medications appear to offer rapid symptom relief from the panic attack while CBT offers an array of long-term coping skills.
Conclusion
During the last 15 years, we have gained extensive knowledge regarding the pharmacological management of panic disorder. We have discovered new agents and learned new strategies. Pharmacologic treatment of panic disorder is extremely effective, with treatment failures being related to inadequate dosage, lack of initial careful management or inadequate length of treatment as the major factors of nonresponse. All of this knowledge has led to more beneficial outcomes for patients with panic disorder.
Table 1DSM-IV Criteria fora Panic Attack
A discrete period of intense fear or discomfort in which four (or more) of the following symptoms develop abruptly and reach a peak within 10 minutes:
- Palpitations, pounding heart or accelerated heart rate (tachycardia)
- Sweating
- Trembling or shaking
- Sensations of shortness of breath or smothering
- Feeling of choking
- Chest pain or discomfort
- Nausea or abdominal distress
- Feeling dizzy, unsteady, lightheaded or faint
- Derealization (feelings of unreality) or depersonalization (being detached from oneself)
- Fear of losing control or "going crazy"
- Fear of dying
- Paresthesia (numbness or tingling sensations)
- Chills or hot flushesDSM-IV Criteria for Panic Disorder
- Recurrent unexpected panic attacks and
- At least one of the attacks has been followed by one month or more of one (or more) of the following: a. Persistent concern about having additional attacks
b. Worry about the implications of the attack or its consequences (e.g., losing control, having a heart attack, "going crazy")
c. A significant change in behavior related to the attacks