News|Videos|November 16, 2026

The Psych Consult: Hypoactive Delirium and Post-Intensive Care Syndrome. What Outpatient Psychiatrists Should Know

A pulmonary and critical care physician explains why quiet, hypoactive ICU delirium is often missed, carries worse long-term outcomes, and keeps affecting patients long after they leave the hospital.

THE PSYCH CONSULT: SECOND OPINION

In this episode of “The Psych Consult: Second Opinion,” host Claire Brandon, MD, and pulmonary and critical care physician Lakshman Swamy, MD, MBA, FCCP, talked about what intensive care unit (ICU) delirium looks like and why psychiatrists who never set foot in the ICU will still see what it leaves behind. Swamy trained in internal medicine and pulmonary and critical care at Boston University and the VA. He now practices in the ICU at Cambridge Health Alliance and works with a value-based care company that provides in-home care, much of it to older, medically complex patients in rural areas.

Swamy said patients often experience the ICU very differently from the people treating them. Sleep and wake cycles are disrupted, alarms go off constantly, and patients lose control over their own bodies, down to routine fingersticks they never agreed to. One patient he saw as a fellow described his stay as “weeks of bedridden torture.”

Two Presentations

Swamy said hyperactive, agitated delirium is what most clinicians picture, and it is usually what prompts a psychiatry consult. In some ways it is easier to manage, because the patient is still engaging with the team and the agitation tends to fade.

Hypoactive delirium is a different problem. Swamy described a recent elderly patient who had come through the acute illness, was off all sedatives, and needed almost no ventilator support, but still did not open their eyes or respond after about 20 days. Neurology, psychiatry, magnetic resonance imaging, and electroencephalography ruled out other causes, and what remained was hypoactive delirium. He called it misdiagnosed, underdiagnosed, and slow to recognize. Treatment requires avoiding benzodiazepines and other GABAergic agents, and really anything that clouds the sensorium, which makes pain control harder.

“The worst part is that the long-term outcomes are so much worse when someone has hypoactive delirium, and that’s what I think a lot of the listeners are going to be seeing when people come out of the ICU,” said Swamy. “Often we will get them out of the ICU, but their lives are never the same.”

He stressed objective screening, including the Confusion Assessment Method for the ICU (CAM-ICU). In one version, the patient squeezes the examiner’s hand each time they hear the letter “A” while the examiner spells a word such as “Casablanca.” Swamy said residents are often surprised to see a patient who seemed fine in conversation fail the test, because the brain is good at hiding dysfunction.

Who Is at Risk

Swamy described risk as the patient’s baseline vulnerability multiplied by how sick they get in the ICU. On the baseline side he listed frailty, older age, dementia, substance use disorders, and untreated psychiatric illness. He said the biggest single factor is pharmacologic: patients who arrive already taking benzodiazepines start out at a disadvantage. Some risks are avoidable, such as patients going without their hearing aids or glasses, or without communication in their first language. He also named social isolation, which he sees often in safety-net settings.

For outpatient clinicians, he offered one practical proxy for illness severity: ask how many days the patient spent in the ICU. A 3-day stay and an 18-day stay carry very different risks.

Implications After Discharge

The term post-intensive care syndrome describes new or worsening physical, cognitive, or mental health problems that arise after critical illness and persist beyond the hospital stay, and it can apply to family members as well as survivors.1 Data from the BRAIN-ICU study back up the cognitive concerns raised in the episode. Among 821 adults with respiratory failure or shock, 74% developed delirium during hospitalization. At 12 months, 34% of those assessed had global cognition scores similar to moderate traumatic brain injury and 24% had scores similar to mild Alzheimer disease. A longer duration of delirium was independently associated with worse global cognition at 3 and 12 months (P=0.001 and P=0.04, respectively).2

Brandon encouraged psychiatrists to validate patients’ persistent symptoms, to have a low threshold for referral to formal neurocognitive testing, and to use evidence-based approaches such as cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia rather than benzodiazepines for sleep problems after the ICU. Brandon also pointed to family members, who can experience a sense of loss when the patient moves from the ICU to a general floor.

Swamy added that outpatient clinicians may be the only ones who ever ask an ICU survivor about their goals of care. “If you open the question and then just give it to them and say, ‘My ask of you is that you go and talk to your family about this. I’m not telling you what to say,’” said Swamy. “I think that goes a really long way.”

The episode also covered clinician well-being. Swamy said role modeling, including talking openly about seeing his own therapist, and regular team debriefs after difficult cases help trainees in the ICU.

Dr Brandon is the founder and medical director of Whole Body Psychiatry. She is dual board-certified in adult psychiatry and consultation-liaison psychiatry, and specializes in gut-brain health.

Dr Swamy is the chief pulmonologist at Monogram Health, practices in the ICU at Cambridge Health Alliance, and is the physician editor in chief of the American Journal of Critical Care.

References

1. Needham DM, Davidson J, Cohen H, et al. Improving long-term outcomes after discharge from intensive care unit: report from a stakeholders’ conference. Crit Care Med. 2012;40(2):502-509.

2. Pandharipande PP, Girard TD, Jackson JC, et al; BRAIN-ICU Study Investigators. Long-term cognitive impairment after critical illness. N Engl J Med. 2013;369(14):1306-1316.

Related to this article